Less than two years ago, a Danish research team released the data of nearly 70,000 people who used a popular dating site so that it would be available for public study. More recently, we’ve learned how Facebook uses our data, Twitter bots share links and a popular education company collected student test data for a research project.
In all of these cases, personal data is accumulated — and manipulated — without individuals’ expressed consent. And while some may argue that using these applications implies consent, others counter that society has reached a critical juncture, and we must consider the moral and ethical questions generated by the growth of technologies such as artificial intelligence, machine learning and Big Data.
Ethics and computer science aren’t natural bedfellows. One of the earliest computer programmers, Grace Hopper, has been quoted as saying, “It’s easier to ask forgiveness than it is to get permission.” That’s pretty much been the modus operandi for computing products ever since: Build it first, then fix it if there are problems.
But the stakes have shifted now that certain technologies have life-changing consequences. Consider a machine-learning application that decides who gets reduced-cost housing or who is eligible for a medical procedure. Consider whether self-driving cars, controlled by AI, are safe enough to be on public roads.
Whether they are developing courses, hosting conferences or infusing ethics into everyday coursework, here are four ways university professionals are getting students to think differently about the ramifications of AI and Big Data:
1. Focus on Real-World Applications of Emerging Tech
Questionable ethics practices related to AI and to data usage and privacy are already popping up in corporations, as well as in governmental and other entities. At the University of Texas-Austin, the course “Ethical Foundations of Computer Science” asks students to discuss case studies to consider the impact of technology on society.
2. Consider Diverse Academic Perspectives for Ethics in Computer Science
Stanford is developing a course using input from the disciplines of philosophy and political science. The goal is to have students consider topics from varied perspectives, such as those of a software engineer, a business strategist or a policymaker.
3. Discuss Existing Industry Standards as Ethical Guidelines
Associations such as the American Statistical Association and Association for Computing Machinery have published standards that can be applied to computer science ethics. Students and professors can debate whether standards like these help to prevent ethics violations.
4. Develop Systematic Methods to Analyze Societal Issues
In Cornell’s data science course, students tackle real-world ethical challenges, such as how to handle a biased data set. In a New York Times article, Solon Barocas, an assistant professor, said the course “was really focused on trying to help them understand what in their everyday practice as a data scientist they are likely to confront, and to help them think through these challenges more systematically.”